Germany's Intelligence Services Enter a New Era
In October, August Hanning, president of the BND from 1998 to 2005 and afterwards State Secretary in the Interior Ministry, the very house this reform comes from, was arrested and accused of espionage and attempted treason. According to investigators, almost 2,000 secret documents changed hands for money, at least until June 2022. Hanning denies it.
A month later, it is official.
On Friday, November 13, the Bundestag voted Germany's intelligence services into a new era. Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt called it a "reform of the century" and a "new reckoning of time".
309 members voted yes, 190 voted no, 71 abstained. CDU, CSU and SPD were for it. The Greens abstained. Die Linke and AfD voted against.
The Länder will not be bothering anyone. The law does not need the Bundesrat's consent.
Up until now, Germany's services collected information. Watching, listening, writing reports. Since the end of WW2, acting on those was left to the police.
Ladies and gentlemen, it is our great pleasure to present the release notes.
⚖️ New: the Verfassungsschutz may delete and falsify data on your devices.
⚖️ New: it may feed false information to those involved. Personalised.
⚖️ New: home visits. With special approval, officers may enter your flat in secret to read your data.
⚖️ New: AI-powered face matching against the entire internet.
⚖️ New: wider access to your payment provider and your phone company.
⚖️ New: a youth programme. In exceptional cases, informants from the age of 16.
⚖️ New: the BND may hack back abroad, take down servers and sabotage IT systems.
Improved: storage. Data collected abroad may be kept unread for six months, metadata for thirteen.
Improved: oversight. The control council grows from six to twelve members.
Practical gain
A service that may add data to a suspect's computer saves itself the trouble of finding it. Lawyer Ulrich Vosgerau put it plainly: a proper state does not put data on a computer that should not be there, creating artificial incriminating material.
We don't want to assume that this is the way it's going to be, but ... what can be used, may be used.
The separation between police and secret services was not an accident. It was the lesson of two German secret police forces that could enter homes, rewrite files and recruit children. Who in the Bundestag still remembers how that ended?
Welcome to the new era. Please keep your devices switched on. The Verfassungsschutz will be with you shortly.